Pop Culture's Problematic Portrayal of Psychopathy. The Owl, bhsowl.org/5097/arts-entertainment/pop-cultures-problematic-portrayal-of-psychopathy/. Melisandre from Game of Thrones. Lynzee Smith When we look at Joe's history, we see that he was brought up in a horrible, mistreated Protective Services came and sent him to a Group Home for Boys in New York. There, youll also find thoughts and questions by our community. ", They're masters of making "the right first impressions, creating this perception, weaving this little web in which they learn about you and stage their entrance into your life," says Neo. Netflix came out with an unforgettable TV Series named "YOU." Penn Badgley played a Realistically, if it wasnt for Joes help, Love wouldve been charged with Natalies murder in Episode 2. Goldberg's penchant for harming or killing those close to his love interest and obsession Beck also suggest he's morbidly codependent, according to Rutledge. "If you're vulnerable because you're looking for someone to rescue you," Neo adds, "then sophisticated psychopaths and dark personality types are going to be out for you. He thinks about himself as a passionate lover and wants to take away all the problems from his girlfriends life even if it means killing her best friend. This is based on his manipulative and often violent behavior towards others, which appears to be motivated by a desire for power and control. In the story, Joe is an orphan, and he is ignored by his parents. It's not like a strep test with 'yes, you have strep,' or 'no, you don't.'". These flashbacks help viewers better understand the root cause of Goldberg's behavior and, according to Scott, these scenes led her to believe Goldberg acts how he does not because he lacks empathy and has antisocial personality disorder, but because his violent and turbulent childhood caused him to develop an attachment disorder. Joe Goldberg is often described as a psychopath, but this is largely because the term "psychopath" has become a popular tag for the (fictional and real-life) violent killers that grace our screens.The term "sociopath" is also often used interchangeably with "psychopath," but the former, in fact, refers to a person with Anti-Social Personality . All of which Joe had experienced as a child. individuals' personal memories and ideas," which why Joe would defend the person he loved to Use good judgment, be careful with someone who tries to get you alone, and don't share where you live straight out of the gate. COMPARISON OF THEORISTS: Joe Goldberg Unlike Joe and Love, both serial killers are typically narcissistic, whereas Joe is a textbook example ofYandere, whereas Love is a typical, garden-variety killer. He is a conflicting character, but I really enjoyed him as a character. As stated in Kwon article, "At first, the "You don't have to kill someone to get that diagnosis," Scott said. Joe had a rough life Guinevere Beck | YOU Wiki | Fandom Some Extremely Baffling Info Has Come To Light About Ellys Time On The Bachelor, 23 Sep 2020 He loves to read their mind and even though he is wrong most of the times, Joe believes he knows women best. What kind of mental illness does Joe Goldberg, the main character of Because when we take care of ourselves and our needs first, "that makes us a lot less vulnerable to a love bomber. Moving away from the bustle of LA and the bloody aftermath they left there in Season 2 to start a new life in the burbs, all seemed well for the newlywed couple. Love does not care about consequences or the messes she makes. Highest Grossing Hindi Dubbed South Films. The cycle must be identified in order to break free. Lets get to the bottom of it, shall we? Goldberg shows signs of antisocial personality disorder, narcissism, and codependency in season 1. ", Joe's behavior could even seem romantic "to those of us who have been brought up on Disney and rom-coms practically IV-dripped into our consciousness. some symptoms of being antisocial. According to Mental Health America, symptoms of codependency include a need to control others and an unhealthy dependence on relationships. In You, Joe Goldberg exhibits "psychopathic traits and narcissistic traits," says Hatters Friedman. Karen Cilli is a fact-checker for Verywell Mind. Which disorder do "You" have?. Spoiler Alert! - Medium Pastoral Psychology, 50 (1), 3952. https://doi- While weve known Joe Goldberg to be the obsessive stalker with murderous tendencies for three seasons ofYou,Love Quinn proved that she was the true psycho of the series in Season 3. While working with Mr. Mooney as a teen, he adopted Joe. Design: Cierra Miller/STYLECASTER. "From a clinical perspective, the word 'psychopath' doesn't mean anything.". While Goldberg never receives an explicit diagnosis in either season of "You," many viewers seem to believe he is a psychopath. The series provides us with blatant symptoms from within the main characters behaviour to warn us about any red flags we may notice in our own loved ones. Fans realised Love was Joe's murdering match when she discovers his neighbour Delilah (Carmela Zumbado) being held hostage in his infamous book vault. When you visit the site, Dotdash Meredith and its partners may store or retrieve information on your browser, mostly in the form of cookies. Goldberg shows signs of antisocial personality disorder. We rely on the most current and reputable sources, which are cited in the text and listed at the bottom of each article. He is a serial killer, stalker and former bookstore manager who, upon meeting Guinevere Beck at his workplace in New York, starts to develop an extreme, toxic and delusional obsession. The reason is the way he carries himself in front of people. ", However, You's characterization of Joe Goldberg isn't flawless. What's Realistic About the Depiction of Stalking in You? In season 2, however, flashbacks to Goldberg's past suggest he could actually be none of those and have an attachment disorder. This included finding . Joe Goldberg'S Obsessive Compulsive Personality Disorder in Caroline He had the potential to be such a good person and the ability to use his great skill of reading people to do more good than bad, but he chose the dark road. But Love was somehow surprised that Sherry and Cary heard her very loud murder admission?! Psychopaths tend to be charming at an initial impression; this is why no one ever suspects Joe in either season, and both fans and characters believe that Joe is a likeable person while the people who are against his horrible deeds are viewed as the antagonists. Abnormal Psych Case Study.docx - Case Study of Joe Goldberg Joe Goldberg - other - COMPARISON OF THEORISTS 1 COMPARISON - StuDocu He is also very manipulative and has a lack of empathy. PloS One, 15 (3), e0229876. "Joe [Goldberg] would be a good example of misdiagnosis," Scott said. According to Scott, a season 2 scene when Goldberg looks distraught after he learns his landlord Delilah has been killed proves that Goldberg does indeed have empathy and therefore doesn't have antisocial personality disorder. I was honestly truly sad after finishing the series, because I believed Joe could have been a good person. 8 True Crime Shows To Stream After American Murder: The Family Next Door, 12 Oct 2020 household that has made him codependent as an adult. growing up, with a dysfunctional family. "adult child" (Whitfield, 1991, pg. When he would be dealing with If you've watched Netflix's You, there's a chance you may have started to second-guess yourself recently. oversee that Joe Goldberg might switch over these theories. Netflix's "You" returned for a third season Friday (and has been renewed for a fourth), following the tale of the. Hence, Joe seems to have a form of ASPD (sociopathy), as opposed to him being a complete psychopath. Joe Goldbergs personality type is INFJ, which is the combination of the three functions (introverted Feeling, which is dominant in this type, moderately developed Sensing and judging), which provides him with an unusual perspective on life that he can use to compensate for his introverted intuition. Pretty rich when you consider Love literally had sex with another man but was withholding that information from Joe, Sherry and Cary in the bedroom: pic.twitter.com/SpytmawrLc, Human Person (@JoyconArtist) October 20, 2021. 'You's' Penn Badgley Says Fans Can't Be Entirely Blamed for Liking Joe Demographics Moreover, Joe's tragic backstory, which includes a mother who abandoned him after he shot and killed her abusive boyfriend and a foster father who locked him in a glass book cage for extended periods of time, establishes the roots of an attachment disorder that make it challenging for Joe to bond with or trust others. "What we can learn from psychopaths like Joe," Neo says, "is that we need to have a lot better boundaries. Then when Joe and Love invited Sherry and Cary over to have sex, Love went beserk when she noticed that Joe was simply fantasising about having sex with another woman. "You can do it in a non-physical way. A lot of this comes down to Love having the luxury of family money, which has always helped to bail her out of sticky situations. On top of that, he normalizes all his toxic characteristics, underlining that he does so in the name of love. The main couple in Season 3 has a very interesting connection. codependent due to his childhood. In contrast to Joe, a Cancer would be someone who would bring out the best in you. And just as Joe had a tragic childhood, which he leverages for sympathy, people in real life can do the same: "A compelling story about how sad their childhood was evokes this caretaker instinct." Indeed, people with antisocial personality disorder are more inclined to break the law than those with narcissistic personality disorder, psychologist Stanton Samenow wrote on Psychology Today. It is equally damaging to a persons psychological, spiritual, or social well-being if he or she is emotionally or spiritually abused. I use my personal experiences with my mental health and health to inform my work. Scott did say, though, that the closest clinical diagnosis to a "psychopath" or "sociopath" is antisocial personality disorder, and that Goldberg does indeed show some hallmark traits of the disorder. Lev cautions that despite the way it comes across in the series, "people with [narcissistic personality disorder], they don't really have much remorse and they don't really feel guilt. It's easy to see how Joe's pursuit of his love object would fit the definition of an intimacy-seeking stalker given the way he pursues Beck, then Love, then Marienne throughout You's first three seasons. 2022 Mighty Proud Media, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Joe Goldberg is the main character of You, the extremely popular TV series based on a series of novels by Caroline Kepnes. In the television series You, a number of personality disorders are observed, including the main characters. Android & IOS users, download our mobile app for faster than ever Bollywood & Box Office updates! Because Joe is a charming character, most people watching the show find themselves rooting for him, even when he is facing the well deserved consequences of his own actions. This is something that's dismayed his portrayer Badgley and that Lev believes is dangerous because people with malignant narcissism won't improve even if they seek out treatment. Joe Goldberg is a character in the novel You, who is a textbook psychopath. We explore Joe Goldberg's personality type, best personality matches, zodiac sign and Enneagram type. Quinn, his son and newfound friends, which shows us a different side of Joe decided it would be a great idea to have him The 33-year-old actor's comment was made in response to Colbert asking him: "Do you have anything to say to the people out there that say they want to date Joe, despite the minor flaw of murdering people?" "It's not a clinical portrayal of a serial killer," Badgley said after defending fans. Joe wants to know you, to protect you, to love you. The first and second seasons' plots revolve around the seemingly normal life of . Malignant narcissists exhibit the traits associated with narcissistic personality disorder, including grandiosity, entitlement and lack of empathy, but also have antisocial tendencies, including a lack of remorse and blaming others for their actions. Ever.". Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. Because . According to Scott, this shift in understanding his diagnosismakes "You" feel like a more realistic portrayal of mental health. Think about it: After Natalies death was basically all wrapped up, Love decided to capture Gil. Hatters Friedman notes there's no single mental health condition associated with stalking. For example, when Beck ex-lover, Benji, whom she did not want in her life anymore. Eventually, Joe finds purpose in keeping Henry safe, and this endeavor becomes a main focus of his. Predatory stalkers are planning to attack their victims and enjoy the sense of power the act of stalking gave them. It is only natural for him to feel whatever he wants to feel and to instantly transform into someone else. Personality Analysis of Joe Goldberg by Sophia LeGris - Prezi Although he has done so much wrong, Goldberg still thinks he is a perfect individual, and lacks guilt to take accountability for his actions or even feel empathy towards the people who he has violated. stressful situations due to how he grew up. Then when she shoved the Conrads in her glass box and Joe tried to think of non-violent ways to deal with the couple, Love handed them a gun and forced them to shoot each other. In previous seasons, it was easy to see Joe as a psychopath due to his severe obsessions and violence with women, but there is more to Joes mental state than meets the eye. Every Person Joe Goldberg Has Killed In 'You' Seasons 1, 2 And 3 Joe does not know his biological mother, Sandy, and he When one problem had finally been dealt with (thanks to Joe, mind you), Love just had to make a new issue to give her life some purpose. Copyright 2023 StudeerSnel B.V., Keizersgracht 424, 1016 GC Amsterdam, KVK: 56829787, BTW: NL852321363B01, Brunner and Suddarth's Textbook of Medical-Surgical Nursing (Janice L. Hinkle; Kerry H. Cheever), Civilization and its Discontents (Sigmund Freud), Business Law: Text and Cases (Kenneth W. Clarkson; Roger LeRoy Miller; Frank B. He cant be in love with anything, no matter how much he is addicted or obsessed with it. Growing up, Joe became parentless when his mother abandoned him, and he grew up in a group home where he was profoundly mistreated by the other boys in the house. It is, however, widely considered to overlap with ASPD, and research shows that a third of the people with ASPD also fit the description of a psychopath. Hence, Joe clearly has issues with codependency, which inform the relationships he forms with women. and respect from his mother, which did not work at the end. You can reach out to the National Domestic Violence Hotline by calling victimconnect.org or the hotline.org. Deerfield Beach, FL: So when we have empathy for someone, it hooks us in. So, to get to the bottom of the You phenomena, we turned to psychologist Perpetua Neo, DClinPsy, for insight on how psychopaths manage to suck us in. They can empathize with peoples problems and understand their emotions. As a result, Lev says that the depiction of Joe throughout You, from the voice-overs that detail his thought-process to the fixation on his latest love object, are "very accurate. Its worth paying close attention to what Joes sign indicates about his personality in either case. Why Do We Sympathize With Psychopaths Like Joe Goldberg On "You style is a defense mechanism intended to ward off feelings of anxiety". self-defense to save himself and his mother from his father. While Joe Goldberg is an extreme type of psychopath, we can't guarantee milder versions won't enter your life. worsened as he got older. Joe devalues his wife, Love, while also gaining his bosss affection in the shows latest season. "People use the word 'psychopath' colloquially to describe a person whose behavior defies social norms and conventional understandings of right and wrong," Kelly Scott, a therapist at Tribeca Therapy in Manhattan, told Insider. In essence, they You offers an extreme example of what can happen when a psychopath enters your life. Joe Goldberg is a Caucasian male in his 30s, who recently moved from New York to Speaking of the swingers night, Love wouldnt know how to be lowkey if her life depended on it and it did. Azevedo, J., Vieira-Coelho, M., Castelo-Branco, M., Coelho, R., & Figueiredo-Braga, M. it shows us a different perspective and puts us in the mind of a person with mental illness. The type of person who follows their own cases in the media, as well as who may contact or cause problems with investigators. Cognitive behavioral therapist Dr. Avigail Lev, director of Bay Area CBT Center and founder of CBT Online, gets more specific, diagnosing Joe with covert malignant narcissism. Joe is not a control freak on the bed and loves his girl to come above him and dominate. While Joe Goldberg is an extreme type of psychopath, we can't guarantee milder versions won't enter your life. Although he seems like a nice guy there is something off about him; he has various personality traits where it seems like he is more than one person. He also tends to hold women hostage when he is interested in them, because he doesn't know how to form healthy relationships. As we see in season 2 and season 3, his troubled childhood and the fact that he was abandoned by his mother seemingly gave Joe severe codependency issues. What's the Difference Between a Sociopath and a Narcissist? It'll mean the world. According to Susan Hatters Friedman, MD, Professor of Forensic Psychiatry at Case Western Reserve University, Joe's behavior is an accurate representation of stalking and falls into several categories in the stalker typology created by Mullen and colleagues, the classification system most commonly used in stalking research. On one hand, the series' central character, Joe Goldberg (Penn Badgley), is the psychotic architect of his own delusional love story. After finding out that he is having a son, rather than a daughter like he had hoped, Joe becomes distraught. A Complex Character: Joe Goldberg From You Joe Goldberg has established specific coping methods when it comes to functioning in high By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider You can stream all three seasons of Youon Netflix. Originally posted by omisteriodasduasirmas. Goldberg wrongly assumes that being in a relationship with a woman means being entitled at all times to her complete attention and marks him as the only significant person in her life. There are three types of killers: organized killers, medical killers, and disorganized killers. Your email address will not be published. Throughout each season, he would stalk the women, and become so involved with their lives that he often ends up getting caught in a situation which compels him to commit unethical and illegal acts in the name of love. Trauma isnt the primary cause of Joes antisocial and narcissistic tendencies, but it does play a big part in the development of such disorders and behaviors. NOW WATCH: Los Angeles loves this innovative taco omakase, pattern of becoming obsessed with certain women, term "psychopath" doesn't hold much meaning, medically speaking, people with antisocial personality disorder, more inclined to break the law than those with narcissistic personality disorder, narcissists fly under the radar because they use their charm, Penn Badgley admits it's 'not entirely fair' to blame 'You' fans for thirsting over Joe, despite slamming them in the past, 6 things you probably didn't know about the making of season 2 of Netflix's 'You', Joe from 'You' is probably a love addict, and an expert says it's more common than you might think. He is incapable of being in love with anyone. : an American History (Eric Foner), The Methodology of the Social Sciences (Max Weber), PSY 255 Trait Theory Short Answer Worksheet, Introduction to Personality Media Analysis Worksheet, Persuasive Essay-Thesis Statement and Gathering Resources Worksheet. He is attractive according to societys standards of beauty, his monologues in the show consist of great humor which makes him a likeable and relatable character, and the way he treats children shows us that hes rather polite, caring, and respectful (obviously not enough to respect peoples privacy). He is a bookstore clerk, and that is where he gained most of his knowledge. A yandere is someone who is initially kind, gentle, and sweet before becoming brutal and deranged at the same time. had an abusive father. "These [are] projections of what a perfect, ideal woman to be in love with [is] to him," Hatters Friedman explains. In fact, both Hatters Friedman and Lev point out that even though Joe may seem like he truly loves Beck, Love, or the other women he obsesses over, the show subtly demonstrates that, like a real-life malignant narcissist, he doesn't see these characters as human beings with strengths and weaknesses of their own.